We follow high standards of editorial integrity on this website to help you make informed decisions. This article may include links to services and products from our partners. We may receive compensation when you sign up, at no cost to you. It does not change our unbiased reviews, evaluations or advice. Please take a look at our disclosure.

The Homebuyer’s Guide to Fixed and Variable Mortgage Rates


Fixed vs Variable Mortgage Rates image
Reading Time: 8 Min

When you’re in the market for a home loan, you’ll face a big decision: choosing between a fixed-rate or an adjustable-rate mortgage. Both types have their perks and points to ponder. Grasping what sets them apart is crucial to picking the one that fits your financial plans and how much risk you’re comfortable with. In our easy-to-follow guide, we’ll unpack the details of fixed and adjustable rates. We’ll shed light on essential aspects, offering valuable tips to help you decide which mortgage type suits your situation best.

Fixed-Rate Mortgages Explained

With a fixed-rate mortgage, you can count on steady interest rates and the same payment every month for the life of your loan, no matter what happens in the broader economy or if the bank’s primary rate shifts. Homeowners who love a sure thing when they plan their finances find this option attractive, as it keeps their monthly home loan costs predictable and free from unexpected changes.

Benefits of Fixed-Rate Mortgages

  • Easier Budgeting: Opting for a fixed-rate mortgage provides the advantage of knowing your monthly payment amount with certainty. This reliable consistency simplifies your financial planning and guarantees that your mortgage payment is stable in your monthly budgeting.
  • Stable Payments: With a steady interest rate, you can precisely split your payments into principal and interest portions. This transparency helps you determine how long it’ll take to clear your home loan, paving the way for a strategic payoff plan.

Risks of Fixed-Rate Mortgages

  • Higher Initial Rates: Generally, fixed-rate home loans start with steeper interest rates than those with rates that can change. Your monthly payment could be a bit higher, specifically in the initial stages of your mortgage.
  • Limited Flexibility: A fixed interest rate ensures the loan’s interest rate won’t change over time. As such, should interest rates significantly decrease, you can only take advantage of lower rates if you decide to refinance, which may result in fees.
  • Prepayment Penalties: Terminating your fixed-rate home loan agreement early could lead to hefty fines. Typically, these fines hinge on the Interest Rate Differential (IRD)—this reflects the gap between the rate you initially received and what’s available now.

Mastering the Flexibility of Variable-Rate Mortgage Options

Unlike mortgages with static interest rates, those with variable rates have interest costs that may change during the loan’s duration. These rates are connected to the prime rate set by lenders, which shifts based on the economic climate and predictions about inflation. When this prime rate moves, your mortgage payments and the rate you pay will change in step. Variable rates offer a chance to pay less when interest rates fall, but they also bring unpredictability into your financial planning.

Benefits of Variable-Rate Mortgages

  • Potential Cost Savings: Mortgages with changing rates usually start with lower interest rates than their fixed-rate counterparts. These reduced rates mean your monthly repayments could be more budget-friendly, particularly in the loan’s initial phase.
  • Flexibility: Adjustable-rate home loans often offer adaptable conditions, which include options like additional payments, settling your mortgage sooner, and the choice to convert to a steady-rate loan if you wish.
  • Lower Prepayment Penalties: Opting out of a variable-rate home loan agreement often involves less severe fees, typically amounting to the three-month interest cost.

Risks of Variable-Rate Mortgages

  • Uncertainty and Rate Fluctuations: The primary disadvantage of adjustable-rate home loans is the uncertainty tied to possible hikes in interest rates. Should rates climb, your monthly mortgage bills might grow, possibly straining your finances and economic security.
  • Limited Predictability: With a variable-rate mortgage, keeping steady financial plans for the future gets trickier because the interest rates change. These shifts can cause unpredictable changes in how much your payment goes towards the loan’s principal and how much covers the interest.
  • Conversion Costs: Should you switch from an adjustable-rate mortgage to a fixed-rate one, be aware that current market rates apply. Hence, if interest has climbed since you first secured your loan, your new fixed-rate mortgage could carry a higher interest.

Determining the Best Choice for You

Deciding on a fixed or adjustable rate mortgage hinges on your financial standing, comfort with risk, and plans. Mull over these aspects to guide your choice:

  1. Financial Stability and Budgeting Preferences: Opting for a fixed-rate mortgage can be ideal if you value predictability in your monthly payments, making budgeting simpler and eliminating worries about possible hikes in your payment amounts. This type of mortgage often suits those who adhere to a tight financial plan and wish to avoid unexpected costs.
  2. Market Conditions and Interest Rate Forecasts: Considering the present state of the market and predictions for interest rates, a mortgage with a variable rate could be an intelligent choice if rates are meager or predicted to drop, as it might lead to cost reductions. Conversely, when rates are low but predicted to climb, locking in with a fixed-rate mortgage might shield you from upcoming hikes.
  3. Risk Tolerance: Consider the level of risk you are prepared to accept and your attitude toward not knowing what lies ahead. A variable-rate mortgage could be a good choice. This is if your monthly budget can adjust to fluctuations in interest rates. However, if you want the exact amount to be paid, a fixed-rate mortgage can be a better option for peace of mind.
  4. Future Plans: Think about what lies ahead, like the duration you aim to live in your house or any significant changes in your life on the horizon. If you’re considering selling or refinancing shortly, opting for an adjustable-rate mortgage could be the wiser choice. On the flip side, were you settling down for many years? A fixed-rate mortgage offers consistency and safeguards you from possible hikes in interest rates.


Making the Switch: Converting Mortgage Rate Types

Remember, you’re not bound to stick with your first mortgage rate choice throughout the loan’s life. Sometimes, you can switch from a variable rate to a fixed-rate mortgage or vice versa if your mortgage provider agrees. Explore these potential options:

  • Switching to a Fixed-Rate Mortgage: I looked into a variable-rate mortgage and now want the consistency of fixed payments. Touch base with your mortgage provider to explore if switching over is possible. Many institutions might let you change to a fixed-rate mortgage during your ongoing term or when it’s time to renew.
  • Switching to a Variable-Rate Mortgage: If you now have a fixed-rate mortgage but believe converting to an adjustable-rate mortgage might help you, you should consider it. Remember that every lender has different policies and costs associated with this procedure, so before making a decision, ensure you understand all possible costs and consequences.


How to Approach Mortgage Interest Rate Negotiations

Though your mortgage interest rates are shaped by wide-reaching financial trends and the rules of loan providers, remember there’s potential to haggle a bit to snag a top-notch rate on your home loan. Bear in mind these handy suggestions:

  1. Compare Rates: Investigate and examine different loan provider offerings to understand average interest rates. This knowledge provides a solid foundation for bargaining and enables you to spot any unusual variations.
  2. Present a Strong Application: Borrowers with solid applications often receive better interest rates from loan providers. A concrete application is characterized by a robust credit record, reliable earnings, a manageable level of debt compared to income, and a significant initial payment.
  3. Leverage Existing Relationships: If you’re doing business with a bank for savings or coverage plans, you might talk them into giving you a lower rate on your home loan. Always ask if they’ve got special deals or price cuts for steady customers.
  4. Ask for a Rate Match: Stumbled upon a cheaper rate? Check with your mortgage provider to see if they’ll match or beat it. Remember, they’re eager to keep you as a client and might be open to negotiating a better deal to finalize your home loan terms with an attractive rate.

Prepayments and Penalties

Knowing about early loan repayment and associated fees is vital if you’re considering a home loan, as they can significantly affect your loan’s price and options. Here’s the essential information:

  • Prepayments: Paying extra on your mortgage beyond your usual installments doesn’t come with a fine and is called a prepayment. Since lenders differ in their prepayment policies, go through your home loan contract carefully to grasp your options for making extra payments and any potential rules that apply.
  • Prepayment Penalties: If you decide to end your mortgage deal early, you may face some prepayment fees. Usually, fixed-rate mortgages come with heftier fines. These are often calculated by comparing the interest rate you first locked into with today’s rates, also known as the Interest Rate Differential (IRD). On the other hand, if you have a variable-rate mortgage, the fees tend to be less and are typically the equivalent of three months’ interest.
  • Open vs. Closed Mortgages: The kind of mortgage you choose affects your options for paying it off early. With an open mortgage, you can make extra payments or switch your mortgage plan anytime without facing fines. Closed mortgages, in contrast, come with limits and potential fines if you try to pay the mortgage off before it’s due.

Variations of Fixed and Variable-Rate Mortgages

Under the broad umbrellas of fixed and adjustable mortgage rates, you’ll discover a range of choices, each with unique perks and characteristics. Take time to explore these alternatives to find one that matches your financial goals perfectly:

  • Open Fixed-Rate Mortgage: With a fixed-rate open mortgage, you can pay off your loan early or switch to a different mortgage period, penalty-free, whenever you wish. This type offers a consistent interest rate while giving you the leeway to make extra payments.
  • Closed Fixed-Rate Mortgage: Your interest rate and monthly payments are locked for a predetermined amount of time when you have a fixed-rate mortgage. It typically offers you an interest rate that is less than that of variable-rate mortgages. It may, however, impose penalties if you settle or refinance ahead of schedule and limit the amount of additional money you can pay early.
  • Open Variable-Rate Mortgage: Choose an open variable-rate mortgage for the liberty to make extra payments, settle the total amount, or change terms anytime — all free of penalty charges. Enjoy the adaptable rates this mortgage option offers without the constraints tied to closed mortgages.
  • Closed Variable-Rate Mortgage: An enclosed adjustable-rate home loan keeps your payments steady throughout its duration but only allows minimal early repayments. This setup ensures predictability and can still take advantage of possible dips in interest rates.

The Impact of the Prime Rate on Variable Mortgage Rates

Grasping the key lending rate, which shapes fluctuating home loan costs, is necessary for those considering an adjustable mortgage. It’s the benchmark charge that top banks in Canada apply to their most reliable clients. This base rate plays a significant role in determining your changing mortgage payments:

  • Prime Rate Fluctuations: The leading rate is shaped by different elements, such as Canada’s economic health and predictions about inflation. Shifts in the prime rate directly affect variable home loan rates, causing them to rise or fall in response.
  • Effect on Mortgage Payments: When the prime rate decreases, more of your payment is applied to the principal balance, helping you settle your home loan faster. On the other hand, when the prime rate climbs, a more significant slice of your payment goes to interest, which can extend the time it takes to pay off your mortgage fully.
  • Interest Rate Caps: Certain moneylenders provide caps on interest rates to shield loan takers from steep hikes in rates. These caps act as a ceiling, ensuring that the rate you pay on your home loan won’t exceed a predetermined limit. It’s reassuring to know that, despite substantial rate increases, your payments will stay within this set boundary.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Which is better, a fixed-rate or variable-rate mortgage? Your choice hinges on your situation and what you prefer. Do you lean towards consistency and certainty? For you, a fixed-rate mortgage might be the best choice. However, a variable-rate mortgage might be a better fit for you if you’re wanting to save some money and are comfortable with rates that could change. Consider your future objectives, present market trends, and financial stability while choosing.
  2. What are the downsides of a variable-rate mortgage? A significant drawback of a variable-rate mortgage is the unpredictability of shifting interest rates. Should rates climb sharply and stay high, your month-to-month payment amount may swell, possibly stretching your finances thin. It’s crucial to evaluate how much risk you’re willing to accept and whether your finances are sturdy enough to withstand possible payment hikes before you decide on a variable-rate home loan.


Deciding on a mortgage type means looking at your money goals, how much risk you can handle, and the current economy. Fixed-rate mortgages give you steady payments, while adjustable rates could lower costs and give more leeway. Consider your budget, plans, and how you deal with the unknown. Be sure to check the small print, including how to pay off the loan early and any extra fees. Talking to a loan expert can help you pick wisely. Balancing the good and evil and your situation will help you choose the right mortgage option.

Save up to $1,200 on fees* with A New BMO Mortgage

when you switch your existing mortgage to BMO between February 1 and February 29, 2024.

bmo mortgages

Author Bio

Mohamed Konate

Mohamed Konate is a personal finance expert, blogger, and marketing consultant based out of Toronto. He is a former financial services professional who worked for many years at major Canadian financial institutions where he managed the marketing strategy around various financial products ranging from credit cards to lines of credit. Mohamed is passionate about personal finance and holds a Bachelor in Business Administration from the University of Quebec (Montreal) and a Master in International Business from the University of Sherbrooke (Quebec).He is also the author of the Canadian Credit Card Guidebook.